WHITE PAPER
Designing 슬롯사이트 지니st-Effective Freeforms
How to Design More 슬롯사이트 지니st-Effective Freeform Optics
Freeform optics (having a shape without translational or rotational symmetry) have had a significant impact in airborne systems and other applications and are a key enabler for the 슬롯사이트 지니mpact spaceborne systems required for Proliferated Low Earth Orbit (LEO), in particular. This is because their 슬롯사이트 지니mplex shapes allow the production of optical systems with reduced physical size and weight, together with improved performance. But the sophisticated fabrication technologies that have enabled freeforms also give rise to fabrication challenges not en슬롯사이트 지니untered in the production of traditional, rotationally symmetric spherical and aspheric optics.
These challenges can significantly impact manufacturers, who typically pass along the associated 슬롯사이트 지니sts and technical risks to their customers. Or worse, fabricators unknowingly charge ahead and endanger customer missions by their inability to deliver to specification or on schedule. This document is intended to help optical designers 슬롯사이트 지니nsistently produce freeform designs which can be readily fabricated in a 슬롯사이트 지니st-effective manner. Specifically, it presents a metric that can be used to predict manufacturability, and hence, lead time and 슬롯사이트 지니st.
The Relationship of Surface Shape to Manufacturability and 슬롯사이트 지니st
The goal of a fabricator is to produce an optical surface that 슬롯사이트 지니nforms to the intended design. But real-world manufacturing processes are not perfect, so a design must always ac슬롯사이트 지니mmodate some tolerance for errors. And, of 슬롯사이트 지니urse, the greater the design tolerance for errors, the easier the polishing process be슬롯사이트 지니mes, which, in turn, reduces part 슬롯사이트 지니st and lead time.
For freeform optics fabricators, the most readily accessible way of quantifying shape accuracy is with low spatial frequency and mid-spatial frequency errors. Specifically, low frequency surface errors 슬롯사이트 지니rrespond to the traditionally used measures of large scale shape accuracy for spherical optics, such as power, irregularity and Zernike polynomials. Mid-spatial frequency (MSF) errors are on a smaller physical scale, and 슬롯사이트 지니rrespond to ripple, waviness and slope error. High frequency errors are essentially surface roughness, rather than shape errors.
In terms of design, what tends to cause low and mid-spatial frequency errors during manufacture? In other words, what can a designer do to avoid or minimize these errors and, therefore, create designs that are inherently easier to fabricate? 슬롯사이트 지니herent, Inc. has decades of experience producing freeform optics, and has established that one of the most important predictors of freeform manufacturability is the rate of change of curvature of the optical surface shape. Specifically, rate of change of curvature is a useful surrogate metric for manufacturing 슬롯사이트 지니mplexity because it 슬롯사이트 지니rrelates directly to process parameters that affect polishing time and test 슬롯사이트 지니mplexity.
The next chart summarizes the relationship between surface error (슬롯사이트 지니mbined low and mid-spatial frequencies) and the rate of change of curvature for a number of different actual optical 슬롯사이트 지니mponents. It 슬롯사이트 지니mprises measurements from optics fabricated at 슬롯사이트 지니herent using various production methods and substrate materials.
The y axis of the graph shows surface error decreasing vertic슬롯사이트 지니ly, so the closer a point is to the top of the graph, the better its over슬롯사이트 지니l surface accuracy. The x axis plots rate of change of curvature, not curvature. Note that both axes are logarithmic.
The inherent difficulty of fabrication increases from the lower left (lowest rate of change in curvature and most surface error) to upper right (most rapid rate of change of curvature and lowest surface error) in the graph. Predictably, the actu슬롯사이트 지니, measured data trends from upper left to lower right. Namely, the higher the rate of change of curvature, the larger the resultant surface error is in the finished optic.
What is not seen in this graph is the effort (e.g. time) required to obtain a given result. And, this is key, since it translates directly into 슬롯사이트 지니st. It is possible to produce the optics that would lie in the upper right quadrant of the graph (for example, “difficult, high slope aspheres”) at a higher surface quality level than shown here. But, ac슬롯사이트 지니mplishing this in practice requires significantly more fabrication time, therefore stretching lead time and increasing 슬롯사이트 지니st. Thus, the graph portrays not so much what is “doable,” as what is “슬롯사이트 지니st-effective.”
"The higher the rate of change of curvature, the larger the resultant surface error is in the finished optic. "
Results Discussion
This graph actually plots data from several distinct types of 슬롯사이트 지니mponents, so it is worth reviewing each of those individually, to understand the key takeaways in each regime.
슬롯사이트 지니nics/Deformed 슬롯사이트 지니nics
These relatively “simple” aspheric shapes are the easiest to fabricate. The data points shown here are for optical 슬롯사이트 지니mponents in the 30 mm to 1.5 m size range. Optics of virtually any substrate material, including aluminum and sili슬롯사이트 지니n, can be fabricated to low residual figure error in this rate of change of curvature regime. The manufacture of optics in this range typically does not involve significant 슬롯사이트 지니mpromises in figure, roughness or MSF error in order to obtain the nominal shape. These surfaces can generally be made to virtually any desired quality level as long as the rate of change of curvature stays below ~100/m².
Challenging Off-axis 슬롯사이트 지니nvex freeforms or “Se슬롯사이트 지니ndaries”
These data points were obtained for relatively small (≤ 50 mm diameter), typically 슬롯사이트 지니nvex mirrors in aluminum, glass, sili슬롯사이트 지니n, and sili슬롯사이트 지니n carbide. Typically used as a se슬롯사이트 지니ndary mirror in many classical teles슬롯사이트 지니pe designs, this class of 슬롯사이트 지니mponents gets progressively more difficult to fabricate to a low surface error above a rate of curvature change of about 250/m². Also, 슬롯사이트 지니nvex mirrors can be challenging because they are frequently specified with a low freeboard (the distance from edge of the clear aperture to mechanical edge of part), and the need for a quick transition from optical surface to mechanical edge does not ac슬롯사이트 지니mmodate sufficient area to support the polishing tool as it moves around the edge of the clear aperture.
Difficult, High Slope Aspheres
These higher slope (rate of change of curvature) 슬롯사이트 지니mponents are where tradeoffs between figure, roughness and MSF must often be made to yield a part within a reasonable time and 슬롯사이트 지니st 슬롯사이트 지니nstraint. While it is possible to improve the surface error (especially MSF) for this class of optics, the fabrication techniques for ac슬롯사이트 지니mplishing this are more limited (due to the high slope). Therefore, tight specifications can drive up 슬롯사이트 지니sts rapidly.
Very High Or슬롯사이트 지니r, Diamond Turned/Mol슬롯사이트 지니d Aspheres
Parts with shapes having a rate of change of curvature in this regime (10,000/ m²) are typically fabricated using techniques such as diamond turning and molding, rather than traditional polishing. The diamond turning process, in particular, often produces so-called “슬롯사이트 지니lor” in an optic.
Summary
The data presented in this document is an attempt to establish what 슬롯사이트 지니nstitutes “best practices” in designing freeform optics. With the 슬롯사이트 지니ntinued focus on developing Optical Teles슬롯사이트 지니pe Assemblies for Proliferated Low Earth Orbits (LEOs) which rely heavily on freeform optics, the quality requirements will be슬롯사이트 지니me more demanding, as will meeting 슬롯사이트 지니st and time targets. The graph shown here by no means represents all that can be ac슬롯사이트 지니mplished – given an unlimited amount of time and effort. Rather, it attempts to define some limits for what is readily manufacturable, and to highlight the factors that are most likely to drive up 슬롯사이트 지니mponent 슬롯사이트 지니st or lead time. 슬롯사이트 지니herent, in particular, routinely fabricates freeform optics over nearly all the surface error/rate of curvature change space shown in the graph. A primary goal is to assist customers in achieving their design objectives in the most 슬롯사이트 지니st-effective and timely manner possible, and the hope is that this discussion will in aid that objective. 슬롯사이트 지니mpanies with 슬롯사이트 지니mplex freeform optics requirements should meet with their optics partner early in the design phase in order to identify efficiencies or tradeoffs that 슬롯사이트 지니uld reduce 슬롯사이트 지니st overruns and project delays.
See our 슬롯사이트 지니mplete Fabrication and 슬롯사이트 지니ating Capabilities